The Reclamation of Madison Hemings

Sarasota has long understood that the past is not a museum piece.

By Edit Sarasota Staff

Sarasota has long understood that the past is not a museum piece. It lives in the stories a community chooses to preserve, the voices it amplifies and the silences it finally decides to examine. The Reclamation of Madison Hemings arrives in that spirit: as a work of performance that places one complicated, consequential American life at the center of the room.

Madison Hemings was born in 1805 to Sally Hemings, an enslaved woman at Monticello, and, according to Madison’s own account, Thomas Jefferson. In 1873, decades after Jefferson’s death, Hemings gave an interview describing his family history, his mother’s relationship with Jefferson and the circumstances of his early life. For generations, that testimony was treated with skepticism or left at the margins of the national story. To revisit it now is to consider not only what was said, but who was permitted to be believed.

The title’s language is pointed. “Reclamation” suggests an act of recovery, but also of authorship: the effort to restore a person to the narrative from which history has repeatedly displaced him. In a city shaped by public storytelling—from its theaters and galleries to its conversations about race, memory and belonging—that work carries particular resonance. Sarasota’s performing-arts community has made room for productions that ask audiences to sit with difficult histories rather than flatten them into familiar symbols. A piece centered on Hemings offers another opportunity for that kind of attentive engagement.

There is also something inherently theatrical about the question at the heart of Hemings’s story: what happens when a person’s own account challenges the version of the past that institutions prefer to tell? Performance can make that tension immediate. It can return historical language to a human voice, allowing audiences to encounter the emotional stakes of testimony, inheritance and recognition in real time.

The Reclamation of Madison Hemings will be presented on Sunday, November 15, 2026, as part of Sarasota’s performing-arts calendar. Organizers have not yet announced the event’s venue; prospective attendees should consult the production’s official listings for the location, ticket information and any updates as the date approaches.

Browse all stories